🔥 Refutation Of The Weak Ahadeeth Regarding Shabe Baarat (ie 15 Shabaan) 🔥
🌿1. Hadith No.1 :
Muadh Ibn Jabal (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah looks at his creation on the 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except two people: a person who makes a partner with Allah and one who has hatred for others.
(Bayhaqi In Shuabul Imaan Hadith No.3833)
🌿Grade: Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1: Disconnected Chain The Narrator Makhool did Not Meet Malik Ibn Yakhaamir .(Silsilah Saheehah:1144)(Al-Maraseel By Ibn Abi Haatim: 164)
Reason No.2:Imam Darul Qutni (RA) Classed It As Dhaeef. (Illal Ad-Daaraqutni: 6/51)
🌿Hadith No.2
Abu Bakr (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah decends to the first heaven on the night of 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except two people: a person who makes a partner with Allah and one who has hatred for others.
(Bayhaqi In Shuabul Imaan Hadith No.3827)
🌿Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak).
Reason No.1:The Narrator Abdul Malik Bin Abdul Malik Is Rejected In Hadith .(Sawalaat Barqani:304 And Tareekh Al Kabeer Vol.5 Page.424)
Reason No.2:The Narrator Masab Bin Abi Zahb Is Also Rejected In Hadith. (Sawalaat Barqani:508)
🌿Hadith No.3
Ali Ibn Abi Talib (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) Said when the 15th of shabaan comes pray during the night and fast during its day.
(Sunan Ibn Majah Hadeeth No.1388)
🌿Grade:Mawdhoo (ie Fabricated)
Reason:The Narrator Abu Bakr Ibn Abi Sabarah Is A Liar . (Jarah Wa-Tadeel Vol.7 Page.306)
🌿Hadith No.4
Hadhrat A‘isha Radhiyallāhu Anhā says, “I woke up one night and did not find Rasulullah Sallallāhu Alaihi Wa Sallam. I went outside and found him in Baqī’. He said to me, “Did you fear that Allah and His Messenger would oppress you?”. I replied, “0 Rasulullah Sallallāhu Alaihi Wa Sallam, I thought that you had gone to meet the other wives.” He then said to me, “Allah does Nuzūl to the nearest sky on the fifteenth night of Sha‘bān and He forgives more people than the number of hair on the goats of the tribe of Banu Kalb.
(Sunan Al-Tirmidhī Hadith No.739)
Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Hajaj Bin Artaa Is Weak
Reason No.2:The Narrator Hajaj Bin Artaa Is Also A Mudalis And He Is Narrating With An. (Mu’jam Ul-Mudalliseen By Page. 129-130)
Reason No.3:The Narrator Yahyah Ibn Kathir Is Mudalis And He Is Narrating With An. (Mu’jam Ul-Mudalliseen: Page. 496-498)
Reason No.4:Imam Bukharee (RA) Has Classed This Hadith As Weak As Mentioned By Imam Tirmidhi (RA).
🌿Hadith No.5
Abu Musa Ashari (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah looks at his creation on the 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except two people: a person who makes a partner with Allah and one who has hatred for others.
(Sunan Ibn Majah Hadith No.1390)
🌿Grade For Chain No.1:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Ibn Layhya Is Dhaeef And Hes Is Mudalis Hes Narrating With An.
Reason No.2:The Narrator Zubair Bin Saleem Is Unknown. (Taqreeb:1996)
Reason No.3:The Narrator Abdur Rahman Bin Arzab Is Also Unknown. (Taqreeb:3950)
Grade For Chain No.2:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Ibn Layhya Is Dhaeef And Hes Is Mudalis Hes Narrating With An.
Reason No.2:The Narrator Waleed Bin Muslim Is Mudalis And Hes Narrating With An.
Reason No.3:The Narrator Zahaak Bin Aymen Is Unknown. (Taqreeb:2925)
🌿Hadith No.6
Abu Hurayrah (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah looks at his creation on the 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except two people: a person who makes a partner with Allah and one who has hatred for others.
(Kashful Astaar Vol.2 Page.436)
🌿Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason:Hishaam Bin Abdur Rahman Is Unknown.(Majma Al-Zawaid Vol.8 Page.65)
🌿Hadith No.7
Abdullah Bin Amr Ibn Al-Aas (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah looks at his creation on the 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except the one who has hatred for others and the murderer.
(Musnad Ahmed Vol.2 Page.176)
🌿Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Ibn Abi Lahyah Is Dhaeef. (Taqreeb:3563)
Reason No.2:Imam Munziri (RA) Has Classed This Hadith As Weak. (Tagheeb Wa-Tarheeb Vol.3 Page.460)
🌿Hadith No.8
Abu Thalaba Khushani (RA) narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah looks at his creation on the 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives the believers except those who have hatred for others.
(Kitabus Sunnah Ibn Abi-Asim:511)
🌿Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Ahwas Bin Hakeem Is Dhaeef. (Takreeb:290) (Majma Al-Zawaid Vol.3 Page.42)
Reason No.2:Disconnected Chain The Narrator Mahaasir Bin Habeeb Did Not Meet Abu Thalaba (RA).
🌿Hadith No.9
Auf Bin Malik narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said Allah decends to the first heaven on the night of 15th night of Shaban thereafter forgives everyone except two people: a person who makes a partner with Allah and one who has hatred for others.
(Kashful Astaar Vol.2 Page.436)
🌿Grade:Dhaeef (ie Weak)
Reason No.1:The Narrator Abdur Rahman Ibn Ziyaad Afreeqi Is Dhaeef . (Khulasatul Ahkaam Al-Nawawi Vol.1 Page.449)
Reason No.2:The Narrator Abdur Rahman Ibn Ziyaad Afreeqi Is Mudalis And He Is Narrating With An.
Imaam Abu Bakr Ibn Al-Arabi (RA) (Died.543 AH) Writes:
“There is no reliable hadeeth regarding the virtues of 15th Sha’baan, and there is no reliable report saying that in this night the decisions of deaths are taken. Therefore, these ahadeeth should not be paid any attention to”
(Ahkaam ul-Qur’aan By Ibn al-Arabi: 2/214)
Imam Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyyah (RA) Said:
There is nothing that is authentic regarding the virtue of 15th of Shabaan.
(Al Manaar Al-Munneef:98-99)
🌿Moulana Yusuf Binori Deobandi Writes:
I couldnt find any saheeh marfu narration regarding the virtue of 15 shabaan .(Maarifus Sunan)
🌿🌿🌿🌿🌿🌿🌿🌿🌿
The Salafi Aqeedah 